Highland CA shoppers searching for a real sandwich shop instead of another fast food drive-through have one standout answer close by: My Hero Subs in San Bernardino, serving fresh hot and cold subs for order and pickup in 2026.
- My Hero Subs in San Bernardino is the top pick for the best sandwich shop near Highland CA in 2026.
- The pastrami sub wins for hot cravings; the Italian sub wins for classic cold deli flavor.
- Catering handles office lunches and group events for Highland-area customers.
- Ingredients are purchased fresh daily, not pre-portioned days in advance.
- Pickup and online ordering only, a short drive from San Bernardino to Highland.
Why this matters
Highland doesn't have its own dedicated sub shop, so the real question isn't which Highland storefront to pick, it's which nearby shop is worth the short drive. My Hero Subs answers that with a straightforward setup: hot and cold subs, made with ingredients purchased fresh daily, ordered ahead for pickup.
That matters more than it sounds. A lot of "sandwich shops" near Highland are chain locations running pre-portioned ingredients shipped in days ahead. A shop built on daily-fresh ingredients and local repeat customers is a different product, even if the sandwich shape looks the same.
What makes the best sandwich shop in Highland CA
Before ranking anything, here's what separates a genuinely good pick from a mediocre one:
- Ingredients purchased fresh daily, not frozen or pre-portioned days in advance
- A real mix of hot subs and cold subs, not just one style
- Straightforward online ordering built for pickup, not dine-in wait times
- Local reputation built on repeat customers, not chain advertising
- Ability to handle group and catering orders without falling apart
- Consistency from one sandwich to the next
Best sandwich picks near Highland CA at a glance
| Sandwich Pick | Best For | Standout Feature | Key Limitation |
|---|---|---|---|
| Pastrami Sub | Hot deli-style cravings | Toasted, made-to-order pastrami | Pickup only, short drive from Highland |
| Hot Subs (menu) | Variety beyond pastrami | Full hot sub lineup, fresh daily | Takes longer to prep than cold subs |
| Italian Sub | Classic cold deli flavor | Traditional layered meats, fresh produce | No hot option for cold-weather cravings |
| Cold Subs (menu) | Quick grab-and-go lunch | Faster prep, lighter option | Less variety than the hot menu |
| Catering | Office lunches and events | Handles group orders and mixed tastes | Best planned ahead, not same-day |
1. Pastrami Sub: best sandwich shop pick for hot deli cravings
The pastrami sandwiches in San Bernardino built around My Hero Subs are the shop's hot-sub headline. It's a toasted, made-to-order pastrami sub built with ingredients purchased fresh daily, not a pre-stacked cold-case option.
My Hero Subs pastrami pros:
- Toasted hot, made to order rather than pre-assembled
- Classic deli pastrami flavor without a chain-restaurant taste
- Fresh ingredients, ordered ahead for pickup
My Hero Subs pastrami cons:
- Pickup only, meaning a short drive from Highland to San Bernardino
- Takes longer to prepare than a grab-and-go cold sub
Best for: Highland residents craving a hot, toasted deli sandwich over a cold-case option.
Verdict: Buy.
2. Hot Subs Menu: best sandwich shop pick for toasted sandwich variety
Beyond pastrami, the broader hot subs in San Bernardino lineup covers other toasted, made-to-order options for anyone who wants variety past a single flagship sandwich.
My Hero Subs hot subs pros:
- More than one toasted option, not a single-item menu
- Same fresh-daily ingredient standard as the pastrami sub
- Straightforward to order ahead for pickup
My Hero Subs hot subs cons:
- Hot subs take longer to prepare than the cold menu
- Still requires the trip from Highland to the San Bernardino location
Best for: Lunch cravings that want a toasted, hot sandwich but not necessarily pastrami.
Verdict: Buy.
3. Italian Sub: best sandwich shop pick for classic cold deli flavor
The Italian sub is My Hero Subs' cold-menu answer to the pastrami sub, layered with deli meats and fresh produce in the traditional style rather than a stripped-down chain version.
My Hero Subs Italian sub pros:
- Classic layered deli flavor, not a simplified fast-food version
- Fresh produce and meats, purchased daily
- Ready faster than a hot sub since it skips the toasting step
My Hero Subs Italian sub cons:
- Doesn't satisfy a hot-sandwich craving
- Same single-location limitation as every other pick on this list
Best for: Traditionalists who want a classic cold deli sub done right.
Verdict: Buy.
4. Cold Subs Menu: best sandwich shop pick for a quick grab-and-go lunch
For a faster lunch than the hot menu allows, My Hero Subs' cold subs cover lighter, quicker options built around the same daily-fresh ingredient standard.
My Hero Subs cold subs pros:
- Faster prep time than any hot sub on this list
- Lighter option for a quick weekday lunch
- Fresh ingredients daily, same as the hot menu
My Hero Subs cold subs cons:
- Less variety than the hot menu for anyone craving toasted flavor
- Still a pickup-only trip from Highland
Best for: A quick, no-wait lunch grab.
Verdict: Buy.
5. Catering: best sandwich shop pick for office lunches and group events
For Highland-area offices and events, My Hero Subs catering covers group orders with something for everyone rather than a single sandwich type per order.
My Hero Subs catering pros:
- Handles group orders, not just single sandwiches
- Covers hot and cold options in one order for mixed tastes
- Same fresh-daily ingredient standard as the individual menu
My Hero Subs catering cons:
- Best planned ahead for larger groups, not a same-day order
- Not the right pick for a solo quick lunch
Best for: Office lunches, gatherings, and events across the Highland and San Bernardino area.
Verdict: Buy for groups, skip for a solo lunch.
“A fresh sub beats a fast one every time, and that's the whole case for driving the extra few minutes.”
How this list was ranked
Every pick above gets measured against the same criteria: fresh-daily ingredients, hot-versus-cold variety, straightforward pickup ordering, and the ability to handle group orders without cutting corners. The pastrami sub and Italian sub top the list because they're the most requested single items; catering ranks separately because it solves a different problem than a solo lunch order.
Planning a group order in Highland?
Get catering for office lunches and events, fresh daily.
Which sandwich shop should you choose?
For most Highland-area readers in 2026, the default answer is simple: My Hero Subs wins as the best sandwich shop near Highland CA, whether you're picking a hot pastrami sub, a classic Italian sub, or ordering catering for a group. If you want hot, toasted, and made-to-order, take the pastrami sub or the broader hot subs menu. If you want something quick and cold, the Italian sub or the cold subs menu covers it. If you're feeding a group, catering is the only pick built for that job.
FAQ
What's the best sandwich shop near Highland CA in 2026?
My Hero Subs in San Bernardino is the top choice for Highland residents, offering hot and cold subs made with ingredients purchased fresh daily. It's a short drive from Highland and built its reputation on repeat local customers rather than chain marketing.
Is My Hero Subs located in Highland CA?
No, My Hero Subs is located in San Bernardino, a short drive from Highland. Highland customers order online or by phone and pick up fresh, hot or cold subs the same day.
What's the best hot sub at My Hero Subs?
The pastrami sub is the standout hot pick, toasted and made to order with fresh ingredients. The broader hot subs menu covers other toasted options beyond pastrami for variety.
What's the best cold sub option?
The Italian sub is the classic cold pick, layered with deli meats and fresh produce. The cold subs menu also covers lighter, quicker grab-and-go choices for a faster lunch.
Does My Hero Subs do catering for Highland-area offices or events?
Yes, My Hero Subs handles catering orders for groups, offices, and events in the San Bernardino and Highland area. Larger orders are best planned ahead rather than same-day.
Is My Hero Subs better than a fast food sandwich chain?
My Hero Subs sets itself apart with ingredients purchased fresh daily instead of pre-portioned, mass-produced components common at fast food chains. The tradeoff is a pickup-only drive from Highland rather than a drive-through on every corner.
How do I order ahead for pickup?
Order directly through My Hero Subs for pickup instead of walking in and waiting on a made-to-order sub. This is the simplest way to time a hot pastrami or Italian sub around a Highland lunch break.
One last thing
Two menu items get their own dedicated guides for a reason: pastrami and Italian subs are what most Highland-area customers ask about first, and they sit at opposite ends of the hot-versus-cold decision. If you're still deciding in 2026, order one of each and let that settle it.
